PrepTest 116, Section 1, Question 1

Main PointDifficulty1 of 5
Passage 1Oil drilling, groundwater contamination, and the limits of hindsight-based regulation
The questionFull text in your LawHub copy of PrepTest 116

The accumulation of scientific knowledge regarding the environmental(459 more words not shown)

Which one of the following(9 more words not shown)

Reading the passage

We've already predicted the problem: we often discover the environmental damage after drilling, and groundwater provides an example. The final paragraph carries that concern forward. Even current safeguards rest on incomplete knowledge, so risks remain. We want that broader point, rather than just one instance of contamination.

Working the answers

  • A

    Contamination is inevitable without appropriate safeguards when the well connects the specified formations. That's different from saying it is inevitable wherever drilling occurs. A also leaves out the problem with hindsight and incomplete knowledge.

  • B

    This is true of the final example, including the international concern. But that example illustrates the broader pattern of learning about dangers after a disaster. It isn't the whole point.

  • C

    Relying on hindsight doesn't establish that hindsight is reliable, much less the only reliable way to write adequate rules. The writer is concerned about the limitations of this approach, not recommending it as sufficient.

  • D
    Correct

    This captures both the continuing risk and the reason: regulation reacts to damage while important questions remain unanswered. Groundwater needn't appear in the answer because it illustrates that general problem.

  • E

    The early rules did neglect groundwater. But the discussion moves beyond that historical mistake to uncertainty about present safeguards and unfamiliar geological hazards. E is too narrow to state the main point.

More Main Point questions

Learn the LSAT our way

Our platform drills Main Point questions at your level and adjusts as you improve.

See plans and pricing

HFL LSAT Advisor

Online

Hi! I'm HFL's LSAT advisor.

Tell me your score and goal and I'll point you to the right plan — or ask me anything.