PrepTest 128, Section 1, Question 24

Author's OpinionDifficulty5 of 5
Passage 4Riddled basins of attraction and the limits of experimental replication
The questionFull text in your LawHub copy of PrepTest 128

One of the foundations of scientific research is(458 more words not shown)

Given the information in the(15 more words not shown)

Reading the passage

Sommerer and Ott's system makes even tiny changes in starting conditions matter enormously. Their work could help explain why repeating an experiment doesn't always reproduce its result. That's the basic idea I'd bring to this question; now we need a statement they would actually accept.

Working the answers

  • A

    Not being able to predict a particle's destination isn't the same as being unable to determine whether a region has fractal properties. No such difficulty identifying those properties is established.

  • B

    This contradicts the specific definition of chaos. Under chaos, a particle's general destination is predictable, even though its exact path and endpoint aren't.

  • C
    Correct

    This supplies the practical link to failed replication. The first paragraph says starting conditions can differ in ways that are “small, inadvertent, or undetectable.” If a scientist can't detect or prevent every tiny difference, exactly recreating those conditions can sometimes be impossible. In an extremely sensitive system, that could prevent replication of the result.

    This is an inference from the explanation, not a sentence the physicists state word for word.

  • D

    Knowing which body of water will receive the spilled water doesn't establish its exact path. The basin discussion supports a general destination outside the troublesome boundary; it doesn't give us this usual ability to predict the precise route.

  • E

    This introduces a different task: reconstructing the route after learning the starting and ending points. The discussion doesn't establish that those two points usually tell us which path a particle took.

More Author's Opinion questions

Learn the LSAT our way

Our platform drills Author's Opinion questions at your level and adjusts as you improve.

See plans and pricing

HFL LSAT Advisor

Online

Hi! I'm HFL's LSAT advisor.

Tell me your score and goal and I'll point you to the right plan — or ask me anything.