PrepTest 136, Section 2, Question 22

Must Be TrueDifficulty3 of 5
The questionFull text in your LawHub copy of PrepTest 136

The airport's runways are too close to each(48 more words not shown)

Which one of the following(8 more words not shown)

Reading the argument

If the schedules plan for sixty landings but the airport allows only thirty, delays make sense. The traffic has been scheduled around capacity that bad weather takes away.

The runway layout explains the reduced capacity: adjacent runways cannot be used simultaneously when visibility is poor. We don't need to assume how many runways the airport has. The figures we are given describe the airport's total allowance: sixty planes an hour in good weather, thirty in poor weather.

What we’re looking for

The question asks what the information most strongly supports. I'd stay close to the connection between the schedules and good-weather capacity. The airlines plan around the more generous landing allowance, which explains why the lower limit disrupts the schedule.

Working the answers

  • A

    Sixty becoming thirty is certainly a reduction by half. But the answer attaches that reduction to each individual runway, while the passage attaches it to the entire airport.

    Imagine two runways each handling thirty planes an hour in good weather. In poor weather, only one operates, still handling thirty. The airport's total falls from sixty to thirty even though the operating runway's rate doesn't fall at all. Those aren't claimed facts about this airport; they show why the overall figures don't establish the per-runway claim.

  • B

    Being allowed to use adjacent runways together doesn't tell us how likely simultaneous landings are at any given moment. The allowance is a rate over an hour, not a report of what happens at every instant. B adds timing information we don't have.

  • C

    The problem is the restriction on simultaneous use in poor visibility. Using runways together in suitable conditions helps the airport accommodate more arrivals. The passage doesn't say simultaneous use itself creates serious delays, much less that using any two runways does so.

  • D
    Correct

    The schedules assume good weather, and good weather permits sixty landings an hour. The airlines are therefore planning on permission for more than thirty landings an hour. This stays at the airport-wide level the evidence describes. It doesn't claim a particular landing rate for each runway.

  • E

    Weather isn't the only possible source of delays. A plane might need an engine part even on a clear day, leaving its flight seriously delayed. Explaining why bad weather creates delays doesn't establish that good weather leaves few or no serious delays.

More Must Be True questions

Learn the LSAT our way

Our platform drills Must Be True questions at your level and adjusts as you improve.

See plans and pricing

HFL LSAT Advisor

Online

Hi! I'm HFL's LSAT advisor.

Tell me your score and goal and I'll point you to the right plan — or ask me anything.